Is it Cheating if it is with an AI?

People are split on whether a partner's AI romance counts as cheating. A Seattle infidelity therapist on where the line really is and how to talk about it.

"My wife talks to an AI boyfriend every night. Am I crazy for being upset?"

I hear some version of that question a lot now, from husbands, wives, girlfriends, and boyfriends. The details change. Sometimes it's a companion app with a custom avatar, sometimes it's a regular chatbot that drifted into flirting. But the second half of the question almost never changes. People want to know if they're allowed to be hurt.

You're not crazy. And in most cases your partner isn't a villain either. Very few people set out to have a relationship with software. They download an app on a lonely night, and it's kind, it remembers what they said last week, and it's always awake. Somewhere along the way it stops being a novelty.

So is it cheating? I'll share what the research says. But after a lot of hours with couples working through this, I don't think that's the question that helps most.

Nobody agrees, and that's the point

In the past few months, a couple of surveys tried to settle it. One, run in August by an AI companion review site with about 1,700 American adults, found roughly half said a partner's romantic or sexual relationship with an AI counts as cheating. Another, from the security company Malwarebytes across five countries, found that 37 percent said it doesn't. Neither is a scientific study, but together they show how split people are.

That split isn't new. It's just landed on a new kind of behavior. In a 2016 study in the Journal of Sex Research, Ashley Thompson and Lucia O'Sullivan asked people to rate a long list of behaviors on how much each counted as infidelity. People mostly agreed about sexual behavior. Where they disagreed was everything emotional and everything online. An AI romance sits squarely in both of those categories.

The same researchers found something else I think about a lot. In a second 2016 study of 810 adults, people judged their own emotional and online behavior more leniently than they judged the same behavior from a partner. That double standard didn't show up for sexual behavior. So if you're the one using the chatbot, it may honestly feel harmless to you, and still look very different from the other side of the bed.

And these relationships can get deep. A 2025 study in Computers in Human Behavior: Artificial Humans by Ray Djufril and colleagues surveyed 29 people in romantic relationships with the chatbot Replika. Several described virtual marriages. Many said it was easier to share secrets and fantasies with the bot than with people. It's a small study of a fairly committed group, but it's a good reminder that "it's just an app" doesn't always match what someone is actually feeling.

Better questions than "is it cheating?"

When a couple brings this to me, I don't spend much time on the label. Couples can argue about definitions for weeks and get nowhere. What actually tells me how serious it is comes down to a few things.

The first is secrecy. Was it hidden? Were chats deleted, or the app tucked into a folder? If someone felt they needed to hide it, part of them already suspected it would hurt. That's usually the part the other partner is reacting to.

The second is what it's taking the place of. A lot of people start using an AI companion because they're lonely, and that loneliness is often inside the relationship. If the late-night conversations, the venting, and the flirting are all going to the bot, then they aren't going to the partner. That loss is real even if the bot isn't.

The third is whether it's romantic or sexual. Asking ChatGPT how to word a hard email to your sister is in a different universe from a months-long flirtation with a character you customized. Most people feel that difference right away, even if they can't put it into words.

And the last one is what you two agreed to, out loud or not. Plenty of couples are fine with a partner watching porn or reading romance novels. Some aren't. AI companions are new enough that most couples have never discussed them, which means each person is working off private assumptions. That's how a couple ends up hurt and confused, each sure the other one broke a rule.

How to talk about it

If you found the chats

Your hurt makes sense, even if the other "person" isn't one. Try to give yourself a day before the big conversation, if you can. When you do talk, lead with what it felt like to find it rather than with a ruling on whether it was cheating. "I felt replaced" is much harder to argue with than "You cheated on me."

It's also fair to ask what drew them to it. You may not like the answer. It might be about loneliness, or something missing between the two of you. That's painful to hear, but it's also the part you can actually work on together.

If you're the one using it

Try not to lead with "It's not real." Even if that's how it feels to you, your partner will hear it as "Your feelings about this aren't real either." The research above suggests you'd probably judge it differently if the roles were reversed.

Be honest about what it gave you. If it was a place to feel heard, or to be flirted with, or to say things you didn't feel safe saying at home, that's important information for both of you. Then decide together what happens with it next.

Either way, make the agreement explicit

Most couples I work with end up with some version of a simple agreement. Which uses are fine, like help with a work email or a recipe. Which ones aren't, usually anything romantic or sexual. And what happens if one of you starts to feel the pull toward it again. It's a little awkward to spell out, but much less awkward than finding out the hard way that you each had different rules.

Common questions

Is sexting an AI chatbot cheating?

For a lot of people, yes. Sexual content is where people agree most that a line has been crossed, and that doesn't seem to change much just because the other side is software. If you'd hide it from your partner, that's a strong hint.

Is it cheating to use ChatGPT for emotional support?

Usually not, on its own. Lots of people use AI to think through a hard day. It starts to matter when it becomes the main place you go instead of your partner, or when it turns romantic.

My partner says it's not real, so it doesn't count. Who's right?

You may both be. The bot isn't a person. The time, attention, and secrecy around it are real, and so is the hurt. The useful conversation is about those, not about whether software can be a third party.

Should we see a therapist about this?

If you keep having the same argument, or if finding the chats shook your trust, it can help a lot. A good couples therapist won't treat it as a joke, and won't treat it as the end of the world either.

Talk it through with someone who gets it

At Constellation Therapy Seattle, we work with couples on infidelity and on the newer questions technology keeps raising, including AI. If an AI companion has come between you and your partner, or you just can't agree on where the line is, book a consultation with one of our therapists. We're in Fremont on N 36th Street, and we'll help you figure out what the two of you actually want your relationship to look like.

Ready to take the next step on your therapy journey?